Understanding Prenuptial and Postnuptial Agreements: A Dive into Lloyd v. Niceta

Red rose on a sheet of music, symbolizing the harmony brought by postnuptial agreements in Maryland

Prenuptial and Postnuptial Agreements: What’s the Difference?

Prenuptial (also known as antenuptial) and postnuptial agreements are two types of marital contracts that can play a crucial role in a couple’s financial planning. A prenuptial agreement is a legal contract entered into by a couple before they get married or enter a civil partnership. This contract typically outlines how assets and debts will be divided between them if their relationship ends. A postnuptial agreement, on the other hand, is similar but is entered into after the couple is already legally committed, either through marriage or civil partnership. Both of these types of agreements can help avoid conflicts and lengthy court proceedings in case of divorce or separation.

How Do These Agreements Compare to Separation Agreements?

It’s important to distinguish prenuptial and postnuptial agreements from separation agreements. A separation agreement, unlike a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement, is a contract between a couple who have decided to live apart and want to formalize their financial arrangements and other responsibilities towards each other. This is often a step towards divorce but can also be a temporary measure.

Delving into the Intricacies: Lloyd v. Niceta

One particularly noteworthy case that provides insight into some of the complexities and potential controversies surrounding postnuptial agreements is Lloyd v. Niceta, 255 Md. App. 663 (2022). In this case, a lump sum provision in the couple’s postnuptial agreement was under scrutiny. This clause held that if Mr. Lloyd committed adultery, he would owe Ms. Niceta a hefty sum – $7 million to be exact. This provision was contested as being against public policy and unconscionable.

The court, however, ruled that while generally, penalties that coerce behavior in contracts are frowned upon, the same rules don’t apply as rigidly in postnuptial agreements. The court argued that these contracts could inherently be viewed as “penalizing” because they might alter the financial agreement between the parties, especially when they are designed to discourage certain behavior that may harm the marital relationship. The lump sum provision was not deemed unconscionable as Mr. Lloyd alone controlled whether this provision would come into play based on his actions.

Why is this Important for your Marital Agreement?

This case highlights the flexibility and enforceability of prenuptial and postnuptial agreements in Maryland. It underlines that such agreements can include stipulations to discourage behaviors that could be detrimental to the marriage. As a party considering entering such an agreement, it’s important to understand that these contracts can carry significant weight in court and should thus be crafted with care.

If you are considering a prenuptial, postnuptial, or separation agreement, or if you need assistance in understanding an existing agreement, it’s wise to consult with an experienced Maryland divorce lawyer. It’s essential to ensure that your rights are protected and that the agreement serves your best interests.


Understanding the nuances of marital contracts can be a challenging task, given their legal complexities and the financial implications they carry. Prenuptial and postnuptial agreements, while similar, serve unique purposes depending on the timing and specific conditions of your relationship. A separation agreement, on the other hand, often comes into play when a couple has decided to live separately, providing a formal framework for their ongoing responsibilities.

Regardless of the type of agreement, the central idea remains the same: these legal tools are designed to protect your interests and provide certainty in uncertain times. Whether you’re looking to get married and want to safeguard your financial future, or you’re going through a separation and need a clear understanding of your responsibilities, these agreements can provide invaluable assistance.

Given the serious legal and financial implications, it’s always advisable to seek expert guidance when entering into, interpreting, or contesting these agreements. If you find yourself in such a situation, don’t hesitate to reach out to an experienced Maryland divorce lawyer. You’ll gain the confidence and clarity you need to navigate these complex legal matters effectively and ensure your best interests are well protected.

Image Credit: Pixabay: Ri_Ya

If you found this article informative, and would like more free legal insights, then don't forget to follow us on Facebook or Twitter using the buttons below.

Would You Like to Comment or Make a Suggestion for a Future Blog Post?

All Fields Required
Your Information Will Not Be Published



Did you like this post? Yes No Not sure


Important Client Advisory:

Due to our high demand and dedication to existing clients, we are accepting new cases for court representation only in appeals within Maryland's appellate courts. For all other legal matters, although we are not entering appearances or attending court hearings, our team is available to offer robust legal consulting services including:

  • Legal Document Preparation: Drafting documents for clients to sign and file, ensuring compliance and precision.
  • Strategic Legal Advice: Offering guidance via phone or email to navigate complex legal challenges.
  • Court Argument Scripts: Crafting detailed scripts for effective opening and closing arguments.

For court appearances in non-appellate matters, we recommend engaging local counsel to ensure the best possible representation and support.